Route 294 is the only bus between Half Moon Bay and the Bay side of the Peninsula. It ends at a Hillsdale Mall parking lot, ~0.6 miles' walk from the Caltrain platforms. Riders coming off a train walk ~14 minutes to catch it home, and it comes once an hour.
Ending 294 at a Caltrain station would cut the trip home by 8–10 minutes, without adding a bus:
Hillsdale Caltrain: stop on 28th Ave at the station, where route 251 already stops. ~10 minutes faster home, and ~2 fewer bus minutes per round trip.
San Mateo Caltrain: puts riders downtown, ~100 feet from the platform. ~8 minutes faster home, for ~3–4 more bus minutes per round trip (~1 bus-hour a weekday).
Each 294 bus already waits ~26 minutes at Half Moon Bay, so neither option needs another bus. Every weekday Caltrain train stops at both stations. Hillsdale Mall's planned redevelopment means SamTrans has to replan this terminal anyway.
Sponsored by Friends of Caltrain, Move San Mateo and Transbay Coalition.
Analysis by Move San Mateo using SamTrans arrival data published by 511 SF Bay; method and sources are on the one-pager below: